The Price of Lawyer Free Speech

An image of a sniper I made on MS Paint that I...

“By placing discretion in the hands of an official to grant or deny a license, such a statute creates a threat of censorship that by its very existence chills free speech.”

Secretary of State v. Joseph H. Munson Co., 467 U.S. 947, 964 n.12 (1984) per U.S. Supreme Court Justice Harry Blackmun

Over the past six months, I have faced a professional conduct complaint initiated by an “anonymous” lawyer and later at the behest of the Law Society of Upper Canada relating to my personal Twitter account: @apribetic.

I won’t go into detail, but suffice it to say that an “anonymous” lawyer did not take kindly to three of my “retweets” or “RTs” and decided to lodge a complaint against me. The fact that both my Twitter account and The Trial Warrior Blog are personal, as opposed to professional endeavours, did not forestall a lengthy Law Society investigation.

Thankfully, I received a letter today confirming that the “Law Society’s Proceedings Authorization Committee decided that discipline proceedings should not be initiated as a result of this complaint and that this matter should be closed.”

Here is a redacted copy of the LSUC letter dismissing the complaint.

For any lawyer to face a formal complaint from a governing law society or bar association is professionally worrisome and emotionally taxing. The fact that the complaint is subjectively frivolous is irrelevant; until the bar complaint is formally dismissed and the file is officially closed, your professional and personal life remains in turmoil.

You can imagine the amount of time it took for me to respond to numerous letters from the Law Society requesting explanations, clarifications and re-clarifications; all valuable time that I will never get back.  The distraction was unnecessary and a disservice to the Law Society’s regulatory mandate.

Admittedly, the Twitter complaint weighed heavily on my mind , as well as my heart.  The price of expressing strong opinions and speaking out against social media fraud is having a large bulls-eye painted on my back.

So be it.

I can take it.

Just next time: stand up and be counted. If you disagree with something I say or write, then call me on it. I am prepared to listen and to be persuaded to change my mind. Just don’t hide behind the cloak of anonymity and file an anonymous complaint. That’s what cowards do.

It helps when you have someone in your corner. In my case, I was fortunate to have the collegial support of not one, but two of the top American criminal defense lawyers and blawgers on my side : Brian Tannebaum and Scott Greenfield. In the latter case, it was Scott’s supporting letter, which in my mind, was dispositive of this “Twitter” complaint.

There is much talk about lack of “civility” in the legal profession.

In the end, civility is neither a substitute for free speech nor an excuse to not expose uncomfortable truths. United we stand, divided we fall.

Related articles

10 Responses to “The Price of Lawyer Free Speech”

  1. shg Says:

    It was my honor to support you.

  2. Antonin I. Pribetic Says:

    As I said before, Scott, I consider you not only a colleague, but more importantly, a true friend. If whenever you need my help, I will be there for you, no questions asked.

  3. coyoty Says:

    You might want to redact the Complaint Resolution Counsel’s signature more strongly.

  4. Antonin I. Pribetic Says:

    Thanks. I have replaced with a fully redacted pdf.

  5. David Whelan Says:

    Glad to hear you’ll keep on keeping on. I enjoy your perspective.

  6. Antonin I. Pribetic Says:

    Thanks for your support.

  7. Randy J. Houlahan B.Sc. Says:

    LSUC should not allow anonymous complaints.

  8. Freedom of Speech & Blogging | RHDefense: The Law Office of Rick Horowitz Says:

    […] Pribetic, a Canadian attorney, reports about an anonymous complaint made about comments he made on the Internet which temporarily […]

  9. Canadian lawyer escapes disciplinary charge for online postings » Digital Age Defense Says:

    […] lawyer Antonin Pribetic reports that for the past six months he’s had to defend himself against a pro… made by an anonymous (at least to him) source who took offense to some of his tweets. That matter […]

  10. Freedom of Speech & Blogging | RHDefense: The Law Office of Rick Horowitz Says:

    […] Pribetic, a Canadian attorney, reports about an anonymous complaint made about comments he made on the Internet which temporarily […]

Leave a Reply

Please log in using one of these methods to post your comment: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: